Thursday, July 29, 2010

Salaries exploded without news coverage

Terry Francke, general counsel for Californians Aware, writes in the Voice of OC online news serivce, "The explosive self-dealing scandal that has in a matter of weeks blown away the city of Bell's senior administrative tier was probably inevitable, given the gaps in the Brown Act and the newspaper publishing tradition that once provided small towns with a watchful eye and a voice to be reckoned with."
    In short, the Bell spectacle is what happens to communities without their own old-fashioned diligent news coverage by veteran newspaper reporters, or at least smart reporters led by veteran newspaper editors. 
    The result need not be on paper, but it must be done with the community memory and professional savvy almost unique to newspaper-trained journalists with experience watching small-town politics. [MORE]
In a related note, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger today in a speech in San Diego challenged cities to post officials' salaries on websites if they have nothing to hide.

In 2003, San Mateo County Judge Rosemary Pfeiffer ruled that the salaries of government employees were secret. Her ruling came in a case where the cities of Atherton, Burlingame, Foster City, San Carlos and San Mateo along with unions representing employees in those cities sued the Palo Alto Daily News over its request to obtain their salaries.

An appeals court upheld her ruling, and the Daily News dropped the case. The now-defunct Knight Ridder chain, which jumped in to assist the Daily News fight the suit, decided to battle the case in a different venue.

Knight Ridder had its Contra Costa Times request salaries for all Oakland city government employees making over $100,000 a year. The unions there sued over the request. A trial was held in Alameda County, and the Times won. The unions appealed and the Times won again.

The unions appealed to the California Supreme Court, which ruled on Aug. 27, 2007 that the salaries of government employees are a matter of public record and must be available upon request to "ensure transparency in government." [Full disclosure: The editor of the Press Club blog, Dave Price, was an owner of the Daily News during the salaries lawsuit, a case known as Teamsters v. Priceless.]

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Get ready for more of the same. Beat reporters, I think, are the most important staff members. Drop columnists before you cut them.
Beat reporters keep people honest. Today the Internet can keep beat reporters honest. We need each other.

Anonymous said...

Yes, the abuses in Bell would have been exposed by a local newspaper. But there's another part to that. You need residents who want to read a newspaper and keep up on civic affairs. I'm worried that we have so many dumbed down citizens, particularly in Southern California, that this kind of thing will happen again and again. People have got to pay attention.