Thursday, August 14, 2014

August 2014 Press Club board minutes

Aug. 13, 2014, 6:30 p.m., Celia's Restaurant, San Mateo

PRESENT: Kristy Blackburn, Darryl Compton, Laura Dudnick, Antonia Ehlers, Jane Northrup, Dave Price, Ed Remitz. ABSENT: Jon Mays, Peter Cleaveland, Marshall Wilson, Jim Watson.

FINANCE/MEMBERSHIP: Darryl indicated there was no change since last month.

HIGH SCHOOL BOOT CAMP: It will be Sept. 26 from 12:30 to 5 p.m. at CSM. The idea of merging the boot camp with the J-Day event sponsored by the Journalism Education Association, Northern California (JEANC) won't happen this year. Kristy, who is apart of JEANC, said that they won't have a J-Day next year, just a session for advisers. So we'll consider the idea of merging our boot camp with J-Day in 2016. Jane, Kristy and Antonia will take on the task of contacting high school advisers about the boot camp.

GRANT PROPOSAL FROM THE TALON STAFF AT LOS ALTOS HIGH SCHOOL: The board unanimously voted to provide a $350 grant for apparatus that will enable students to use their smartphones to shoot high-quality news video. There was some discussion about whether the club, with its revenues declining should be making grants. It was agreed that the board would talk about its finances at next month's meeting.

NEWSLETTER: Laura suggested that the club scrap the newsletter and use Facebook instead. The idea was unanimously approved. Members who receive the emailed newsletter will be notified about the change. Laura volunteered to take on the task of posting information on Facebook.

STEVE O'DONOGHUE'S PROPOSAL FOR A STATEWIDE JOURNALISM ALLIANCE: Directors received an email Aug. 5 about the alliance. O'Donoghue will provide more information at a meeting at the Marines Memorial in SF on Dec. 4.

O'Donoghue stated: "I am in conversations with CNPA about a concept where there would be one umbrella journalism organization for the entire state, horizontally and vertically. That is, high school, community college, university and professional levels, educators, reporters, publishers. The idea is each individual entity would remain autonomous in terms of its mission and activities, but combine for business and advancement of the cause. E.g., one large non-profit where we pool endowments, investments, to increase revenue. We share services (e.g., conference booking, registration), combine for First Amendment fights regardless of level, and perhaps set up regional groups to improve resources for far flung corners of the state." Directors said they were open to the idea, although Dave wondered what it would cost.

JOURNALISM CONTEST JUDGING: Darryl said we would get entries from Florida in September.

The meeting was adjourned at 8:20 p.m. Minutes taken by Secretary Dave Price.

4 comments:

Nina Zhito said...

I am dismayed and concerned to learn that the Board has chosen to abandon the newsletter and to migrate this information to Facebook instead. In so doing, interested journalists who do not participate in FB (yes, we exist) are excluded. What was the rationale for this decision?

Nina Zhito said...

This journalist is dismayed and concerned by the hasty and short-sighted decision to abandon the newsletter and migrate content to Facebook. As a reminder, not everyone participates in -- or believes in FB -- as a newsletter equivalent. Why was this deemed necessary and what discussion ensued?

Nina Zhito said...

may I add thus is my third attempt now to publish a remark
using my iPhone: if this isn't posted a hard copy to the Board will be forthcoming.

Nina Zhito said...

August 20, 2014

This is a now a fourth attempt to post my thoughts about the Board's hasty --and in my opinion exclusionary-- decision to "scrap (sic)" the newsletter and migrate it to Facebook. It may be surprising to Ms. Dudnick who suggested it, and to the Board, but not all journalists who follow the Peninsula Press Club activities and Bay Area media matters participate in FB, and for a host of reasons. FB is neither universally embraced by nor accessible to non-FB members.

Almost half of the Board was absent from this meeting. This was not an agendized proposal or discussion item, and missing members were therefore unable to discuss and vote on a such a key issue.

I formally request that that the Board members enumerate their reasons for "scrapping" the newsletter, and for the record to state what discussion --if any--accompanied this, in my opinion, precipitous decision. I respectfully challenge both the wisdom of this decision, and its validity.

Sincerely,

Nina Zhito
Photojournalist